Sarah Murnaghan’s Two Double Lung Transplants Inspiring and Sobering

3,984 2 Loading

SH 173_#1 BIG

Sarah Murnaghan just turned eleven years old. She wouldn’t be here but for two lung donors, a crack team of surgeons, and a last-minute suspension of the rules.

Sarah suffered from cystic fibrosis from birth. In early 2013, her condition began to quickly deteriorate. She was number one on the list waiting for child lung donors, but her condition wouldn’t wait. That’s when her family appealed to the courts to change a rule preventing Sarah from getting a pair of adult lungs.

While Sarah was first on the list for lungs from child donors—which are in short supply— she was not first on the list for the more abundant supply of adult lungs. Under the current system, children over 12 are given preference for adult lungs.

Dr. Stuart Sweet helped write the rules on child transplants. He told CNN, "We've built a system that tries to be as fair to everyone as possible." The rules take into account age, severity of a patient’s condition, and probability of survival. Ultimately, however, dictating who lives and who dies is an impossible decision.

A judge ordered that the rule be suspended for Sarah, and she got her lungs. But even that wasn’t enough. The first pair of lungs began to fail hours after surgery. Doctors removed the new lungs and placed Sarah on a lung and heart bypass machine for three days, at which point a second pair of lungs became available.

The new transplants were infected with pneumonia but otherwise healthy, and Sarah has since gone home from the hospital.

Cases like Sarah’s are simultaneously inspiring and sobering. 79 people receive a donated organ daily, but due to a chronic undersupply, another 18 die waiting. Although lung transplants have improved over the years, they are still dangerous business. Only half of all transplant patients in the US survive over five years.

In the first year, acute rejection is treatable with immunosuppressants. Later, however, patients suffer from a condition known as chronic rejection where lung function progressively deteriorates. There is no known treatment.

Organovo 3D bioprinter.

Organovo 3D bioprinter.

But, just as procedures like double lung transplants have become available and almost routine in the last two decades, looking forward, emerging technologies may address the twin specters of limited supply and organ rejection.

Doctors used stem cells to reduce the likelihood of rejection in a 2008 trachea transplant. The procedure still required a donor windpipe—which was stripped of its host cells and used as a scaffold for the patient’s own stem cells—but it was successful. We wrote about a similar procedure in 2010, this time the recipient was about the same age as Sarah Murnaghan.

In the future, doctors hope to grow entire organs, including hearts, lungs, and even brains without a donor organ scaffold. Or if you would rather not grow an organ, you might be able to 3D print it—Organovo is pioneering 3D bioprinters that in the short term will help researchers study the effect of drugs on human tissue. But the firm's long term goal is printing custom organs on demand.

Lab-grown organs and bioprinting have plenty of challenges ahead—not the least of which may be political or bureaucratic. But they also promise to increase supply, limit rejection, and allow for more timely treatment.

Dr. David Gerber of UNC Chapel Hill outlines how the future may look, "You're seeing a patient; you're scheduling them for their surgery; you're doing their surgery at an optimum time for them with respect to their health state, their disease state, rather than waiting until they're the sickest patient to get their transplant. So, you're...getting to people when their disease becomes a burden, before their life becomes threatened."

Image Credit: Hey Paul Studios/Flickr, Organovo/YouTube

Jason Dorrier

Jason is managing editor of Singularity Hub. He cut his teeth doing research and writing about finance and economics before moving on to science, technology, and the future. He is curious about pretty much everything, and sad he'll only ever know a tiny fraction of it all.

Discussion — 2 Responses

  • fieryglimmer November 5, 2013 on 8:56 pm

    Sad. I have a friend whose daughter has CF and diabetes. They are too poor to do anything, and are certainly not on the top of the “list”.

  • gfredb November 12, 2013 on 8:28 pm

    Your friend’s daughter is going to die due to the system of organ donations.
    Actually there is no list, it is totally up to the hospital and the doctors as to who receives the transplant. Your friend is poor and has no power to get the transplant. Don’t ever believe that the actual list exists. Whenever your friend’s daughter is admitted to the hospital, she will be admitted with a condition that provides the doctors and the hospital a reason to deny the transplant. My son died from liver disease and he was admitted to the hospital with a diagnosis of kidney failure. Since he was admitted for kidney disease the hospital was not required to give him a liver transplant. The rich get rich. The poor get poorer and then get to supply organs to the rich.