Explore Topics:
AIBiotechnologyRoboticsComputingFutureScienceSpaceEnergyTech
Artificial Intelligence

fMRI Used as Evidence in Sentencing for Murderer

Aaron Saenz
Dec 02, 2009

Share

Brian Dugan's attorney used fMRI evidence during his sentencing for the murder of Jeanine Nicarico (right).

Magnetic resonance imaging has been hailed as a possible means of creating the ultimate lie detector. Yet the first publicized fMRI evidence admitted into a US court was not used to separate fact from fiction, but to prove that a murderer was a real psychopath. Brian Dugan was already serving a life sentence for two murders when he was indicated in the 1983 rape and murder of a third, Jeanine Nicarico. In July of this year, Dugan pleaded guilty to killing the young girl. During the sentencing hearings that followed, Dugan's lawyer, Steve Greenberg, introduced fMRI scans as evidence that his client suffered from a clear case of psychopathy. While Dugan was ultimately sentenced to death, the jury's 5+ hour deliberation of the case may indicate that fMRI scans could become an important tool for defense attorneys in the US legal system.

Greenberg's expert witness was Dr. Kent Kiehl, a researcher at the University of New Mexico. Kiehl regularly performs fMRI scans on prisoners as part of his studies in psychopathy and moral reasoning. According to Kiehl, Dugan has 37 out of 40 markers for the condition, placing him in the 99.5 percentile. Yet the prosecution argued, with the help of its own expert Jonathan Brodie of NYU, that a mental illness such as psychopathy does not mitigate the results of Dugan's actions and that a scan in 2009 could not accurately reflect the state of mind of someone in 1983. The jury deliberated for five hours, notified the judge that they had reached a decision, but then asked for more time. Following a sequestered night, the jury met again before delivering the death sentence. The jury, before returning for further deliberation, was originally looking to give Dugan a life sentence, so Greenberg is seeking an appeal.

Be Part of the Future

Sign up to receive top stories about groundbreaking technologies and visionary thinkers from SingularityHub.

100% Free. No Spam. Unsubscribe any time.

While PET scans, and brain abnormalities have been used in cases before, this is the first time that a fMRI scan has been admitted as evidence of a defendant's mental or moral state. Of course, sentencing hearings in the US are less strict than trials in the admission of evidence. We are a long way away from knowing if fMRIs can be accepted as proof that a defendant (or witness) is lying about an event.

[photo credit: Sun Times]

Related Articles

Characters from the video game minecraft

DeepMind’s New AI Teaches Itself to Play Minecraft From Scratch

Shelly Fan
A 3D digiral render of a colorful, brain-like structure

What Anthropic Researchers Found After Reading Claude’s ‘Mind’ Surprised Them

Edd Gent
Bleeding Edge video game from Microsoft's Ninja Theory.

This Microsoft AI Studied 7 Years of Video-Game Play. Now It Dreams Up Whole New Game Scenarios.

Shelly Fan
Characters from the video game minecraft
Artificial Intelligence

DeepMind’s New AI Teaches Itself to Play Minecraft From Scratch

Shelly Fan
A 3D digiral render of a colorful, brain-like structure
Artificial Intelligence

What Anthropic Researchers Found After Reading Claude’s ‘Mind’ Surprised Them

Edd Gent
Bleeding Edge video game from Microsoft's Ninja Theory.
Artificial Intelligence

This Microsoft AI Studied 7 Years of Video-Game Play. Now It Dreams Up Whole New Game Scenarios.

Shelly Fan

What we’re reading

Be Part of the Future

Sign up to receive top stories about groundbreaking technologies and visionary thinkers from SingularityHub.

100% Free. No Spam. Unsubscribe any time.

SingularityHub chronicles the technological frontier with coverage of the breakthroughs, players, and issues shaping the future.

Follow Us On Social

About

  • About Hub
  • About Singularity

Get in Touch

  • Contact Us
  • Pitch Us
  • Brand Partnerships

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
© 2025 Singularity