Moore’s Law: Scientists Just Made a Graphene Transistor Gate the Width of an Atom

There’s been no greater act of magic in technology than the sleight of hand performed by Moore’s Law. Electronic components that once fit in your palm have long gone atomic, vanishing from our world to take up residence in the quantum realm.

But we’re now brushing the bitter limits of this trend. In a paper published in Nature this week, scientists at Tsinghua University in Shanghai wrote that they’ve built a graphene transistor gate with a length of 0.34 nanometers (nm)—or roughly the size of a single carbon atom.

The gate, a chip component that switches transistors on and off, is a critical measure of transistor size. Previous research had already pushed gate lengths to one nanometer and below. By scaling gate lengths down to the size of single atoms, the latest work sets a new mark that’ll be hard to beat. “In the future, it will be almost impossible for people to make a gate length smaller than 0.34 nm,” the paper’s senior author Tian-Ling Ren told IEEE Spectrum. “This could be the last node for Moore’s Law.”

Etching a 2D Sandwich

Transistors have a few core components: the source, the drain, the channel, and the gate. Electrical current flows from the source, through the channel, past the gate, and into the drain. The gate switches this current on or off depending on the voltage applied to it.

Recent advances in extreme transistor gate miniaturization rely on some fascinating materials. In 2016, for example, researchers used carbon nanotubes—which are single-atom-thick sheets of carbon rolled into cylinders—and a 2D material called molybdenum disulfide to achieve a gate length of one nanometer. Silicon is a better semiconductor, as electrical currents encounter more resistance in molybdenum disulfide, but when gate lengths dip below five nanometers, electrons leak across the gates in silicon transistors. Molybdenum disulfide’s natural resistance prevents this leakage at the tiniest scales.

Building on this prior work, the researchers in the most recent study also chose molybdenum disulfide for their channel material and a carbon-based gate. But instead of carbon nanotubes, which are a nanometer across, they looked to go smaller. Unroll a nanotube and you get a sheet made of carbon atoms called graphene. Graphene has all kinds of interesting properties, one of which is excellent conductivity. The width and length of a graphene sheet are, of course, bigger than a nanotube—but the edge is a single carbon atom thick. The team cleverly exploited this property.

First they laid down a layer of silicon dioxide for the base structure. Then, using a graphene production method called chemical vapor deposition, they laid a sheet of graphene on top of the silicon dioxide and a layer of aluminum oxide on top of the graphene. The aluminum oxide and silicon dioxide sandwiching the graphene act as insulators, effectively cutting off its electrical properties from the rest of the transistor. They then etched into the sandwiched materials to create a step—the same shape as the stairs in your home—and in the process, exposed the edge of the graphene sheet in the vertical wall of the step, thus making an atomically thin gate. They call this construction a “sidewall transistor.”

Finally, over the step, the team laid down a layer of hafnium oxide—to add a little space between gate and channel—and a layer of molybdenum disulfide to form the channel. They then added two metal electrodes, one on the top step and one on the bottom, as source and drain.

moore's law sidewall transistor graphene gate
A sidewall transistor with a graphene gate. Image Credit: Wu, F., Tian, H., Shen, Y. et al. Vertical MoS2 transistors with sub-1-nm gate lengths. Nature 603, 259–264 (2022).

Critically, the new technique doesn’t require the researchers to precisely position the graphene to make the gate work. This is one of the big challenges of using carbon nanotubes—it’s no mean feat getting them to settle in exactly where they’re needed.

More Moore

To be clear, the work is a proof of concept: The researchers haven’t meaningfully scaled the approach. Fabricating a handful of transistors isn’t the same as manufacturing billions on a chip and flawlessly making billions of those chips for use in laptops and smartphones. Ren also points out that 2D materials, like molybdenum disulfide, are still pricey and manufacturing high-quality stuff at scale is a challenge.

New technologies like gate-all-around silicon transistors are more likely to make their way into your laptop or phone in the next few years. Also, it’s worth noting that the upshot of Moore’s Law—that computers will continue to get more powerful and cheaper at an exponential rate—can also be driven by software tweaks or architecture changes, like using the third dimension to stack components on top of one another.

Still, the research does explore and better define the outer reaches of miniaturization, perhaps setting a lower bound that may not be broken for years. It also demonstrates a clever way to exploit the most desirable properties of 2D materials in chips. And if further refined, the approach, which doesn’t rely on the exact positioning of components and leans on already common chipmaking technologies, does seem to have some potential to scale.

Regardless, shrinking the size of electronic components from inches to atoms over a relatively short span of decades remains one of science and technology’s niftiest tricks—and this work takes the trend to a new extreme.

Image Credit: Yulissa Tagle / Unsplash



Looking for ways to stay ahead of the pace of change? Rethink what’s possible.  Join a highly curated, exclusive cohort of 80 executives for Singularity’s flagship Executive Program (EP), a five-day, fully immersive leadership transformation program that disrupts existing ways of thinking. Discover a new mindset, toolset and network of fellow futurists committed to finding solutions to the fast pace of change in the world. Click here to learn more and apply today!

Jason Dorrier
Jason Dorrier
Jason is editorial director of Singularity Hub. He researched and wrote about finance and economics before moving on to science and technology. He's curious about pretty much everything, but especially loves learning about and sharing big ideas and advances in artificial intelligence, computing, robotics, biotech, neuroscience, and space.
Don't miss a trend
Get Hub delivered to your inbox